1. Remington Bar And Casino Whitefish
2. Remington Bar And Casino Whitefish Montana
3. Remington Bar And Casino Whitefish Mt

The restraining orders were filed against Sykes Diner and Market, and Scotty’s Bar in Kalispell, The Remington Bar in Whitefish, as well as the Ferndale Market, and Your Lucky Turn Casino and Mercantile in Big Fork. So far, the court has refrained from shutting them down and has scheduled hearings in early November. The lawsuits were filed Friday in Flathead County District Court against Sykes Diner in Kalispell, The Remington Bar in Whitefish and the Ferndale Market and Your Turn Mercantile/Your Lucky Turn. A map showing Remington Bar and Casino, located in Whitefish at 130 Central Avenue, in Montana, United States.

The Montana Department of Public Health and Human Services has lodged complaints against four Flathead County businesses alleging the entities violated COVID-19 directives by failing to ensure employees and patrons wore masks and that the establishments displayed proper signage related to COVID-19 protocols.

The lawsuits were filed Friday in Flathead County District Court against Sykes Diner in Kalispell, The Remington Bar in Whitefish and the Ferndale Market and Your Turn Mercantile/Your Lucky Turn Casino in Bigfork. The businesses have been given 21 days to respond to the complaints, according to court documents filed Friday.

The state health department had sought an immediate injunction that would have required the businesses to immediately shut down via restraining orders and called for the Flathead County Sheriff’s Department to enforce the measure. As part of the request, the businesses would be allowed to reopen only after they submitted plans that would implement measures to comply with the state’s mask directive and other public health orders.

But multiple Flathead County District Court judges decided not to impose those measures. Instead, summons were filed giving the businesses three weeks to respond to the charges, meaning the businesses can continue to operate until further action has been decided upon.

As of Friday afternoon, owners and employees with three of the businesses said they had not yet been made aware of the charges filed against them. One business, The Remington Bar, could not be reached by phone for comment.

An owner of Sykes Diner said she could not comment on the lawsuit considering she had not read any documents. A manager of Your Turn Mercantile and its sister casino had also not reviewed any information, but said “we have tried our best to comply with health regulations. We don’t chase down every customer that runs through the door. We simply don’t have time for that.”

According to court documents, all four businesses were visited by state health inspectors on Oct. 20 and again on Oct. 21. At each of the establishments, sanitarians reportedly observed both employees and customers were either not wearing masks or were wearing them incorrectly around the chin or neck as opposed to over the mouth and nose.

As one example, in the case against Sykes Diner, the complaint alleges sanitarians “observed that none of the approximately seven employees visibly present were wearing masks.” A similar observation was made the following day when the same sanitarians noted five employees were not wearing masks.

In the case against The Remington Bar, sanitarians alleged “none of the 60 to 80 patrons visibly present throughout the business space were observed to be wearing masks.” In addition, they noted a portion of servers and bartenders were either not wearing masks or had them donned incorrectly.

Remington Bar And Casino Whitefish

THE ALLEGATIONS were the subject of a Thursday news conference with Gov. Steve Bullock. State health officials announced they were seeking temporary restraining orders against the establishments, which they described as being “repeat offenders” of public health orders.

All four lawsuits touch on a history of citizen complaints at the establishments involving COVID-19 regulations. The state alleges that these patterns, combined with two consecutive days of failing to ensure staff and guests wore masks, means “it is clear that Defendant intends to continue operations in violation of the Mask Directive.”

The order in question states “all businesses, government offices, or other persons responsible for indoor spaces open to the public shall require and take reasonable measures to ensure that all employees, contractors, volunteers, customers, or other members of the public wear a face covering that covers their mouth and nose at all times while entering or remaining in any indoor spaces open to the public.”

During the press call, Flathead and Yellowstone counties were highlighted as COVID-19 hot spots, but Bullock said he was especially concerned about Flathead County, which tallied 62 new cases on Friday, bringing the area’s active case count to 859.

“I’ve heard from hospital leaders from the area that the situation is getting serious and our health-care workers are stretched thin,” Bullock said. “I’ve heard from business owners that [they] want to stay open and not loose employees or customers to this virus.”

But according to Flathead County Attorney Travis Ahner, although Bullock has honed in on the valley’s outbreak, Flathead County has not received adequate support from the state.

“The concern that I have is that the governor awhile back said these [Flathead and Yellowstone] are our two problem areas. The response in Yellowstone was that the state provided funding to help staff the local health department and to help with contact tracing,” Ahner said. “Our health department has also made it very clear that they need more staff and more help, but they haven’t received the same support that Yellowstone has.”

Ahner also said he believes the complaints brought against the four local businesses are misguided and lack evidence when it comes to the role those businesses play in Flathead County’s outbreak.

Remington Bar And Casino Whitefish Montana

He pointed to a recent announcement from the Flathead City-County Health Department in which officials said investigations had linked recent cases to indoor gatherings and large events, not specifically to bars, restaurants, gas stations or other similar businesses.

“When we don’t have any data that specifically ties cases to these places and their actions, that to me, is of note,” Ahner said. “How did they pick these places versus others? These businesses have already been through enough without another shut down.”

Individuals cannot file a consumer complaint form against businesses that appear to be violating COVID-19 guidelines. The complaint form available at https://dphhs.mt.gov/publichealth/FCSS/ConsumerComplaintForm

After a long day of testimony, a Flathead County judge declined state requests for preliminary injunctions against five local businesses accused of violating Montana Gov. Steve Bullock's masking and social-distancing mandates.

Flathead County District Judge Dan Wilson ruled Thursday afternoon that the state Department of Public Health and Human Services failed to justify immediate action against the five businesses. Wilson also declined to award the businesses legal fees but said he would be 'highly inclined' to do so if the state continues pushing for a restraining order and does not present a stronger case. It wasn't immediately clear if the DPHHS would continue pursuing such an order.

The legal setback for the state comes as Flathead County remains a hot spot for coronavirus infections and county officials have punted responsibility for enforcing public health measures, placing immense burdens on local hospitals and contact tracers. Montana reported 962 new cases of COVID-19 on Thursday, including 101 in Flathead County. At least 472 people in the state have died of the disease.

The businesses facing legal action include Sykes Diner and Scotty's Bar in Kalispell, the Ferndale Market and Your Turn Mercantile-Your Lucky Turn Casino near Bigfork, and the Remington Bar in Whitefish. DPHHS sued them individually in late October after sending inspectors who took photos of maskless employees and customers, and signed affidavits about their observations. District Court judges later consolidated the cases into a single hearing because the complaints were legally and factually similar.

Thursday's hearing was often contentious. Early on, Wilson told a spectator he needed to wear a mask or a face shield; the man exited the courtroom claiming he had a medical exemption, which the judge said he doubted. Wilson also repeatedly chided state attorneys, once for the phrasing of a testimony objection, and several times for speaking faster than the court reporter could transcribe.

For each business, an employee or owner testified that they have strived to abide by Bullock's July 15 directive, and several contended they have exceeded the requirements of the order by offering masks to customers and implementing stringent cleaning regimens. They also said they would lose employees, alienate customers and risk going out of business if they crack down on mask enforcement.

'It's a big backlash in Whitefish,' said Dave Sheeran, owner of the Remington Bar. 'About half of my customers are for the mask mandate. About half of my customers are against it. No matter what happens to me today, I'm going to piss off half of my customers.'

Multiple Remington employees have caught COVID-19, prompting the bar to voluntarily close more than once. Sheeran was represented by Kalispell attorney Connor Walker; the other four businesses were represented by Kalispell attorneys Bruce Fredrickson and Angela LeDuc.

Doug White, owner of Your Turn Mercantile and Your Lucky Turn Casino, testified that one of his young employees quit after being threatened by an older male customer. The customer, according to White, placed his hand on his sidearm and told the cashier, 'Why don't you make me put my mask on?'

In another instance, White said a customer cursed at his granddaughter when she asked him to don a face covering.

'I'm not going to put my family or my employees into that situation again,' he said.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and a vast majority of public health experts agree that face masks, including non-medical-grade cloth masks, are effective at mitigating the spread of the coronavirus when a high percentage of the population wears them.

DPHHS attorneys Nick Domitrovich and Robert Lishman, who participated in Thursday's hearing via Zoom, argued the businesses had not undertaken 'reasonable' or 'good-faith' efforts to enforce the mask mandate. That, they argued, was clear from the number of maskless customers the inspectors observed while visiting the businesses on three consecutive days in October.

The state attorneys noted that the Ferndale Market placed a sign at its entrance notifying people of the mask requirement. The sign, however, also gave customers tacit approval to flout the requirement. It claimed a federal privacy law prohibits employees from asking about customers' health, and so the store would assume all maskless patrons have valid medical exemptions.

'In this case, we believe that we presented direct evidence that some of the defendants had signs that were not compliant with the mask directive,' Domitrovich said. 'When our inspectors visited those businesses, the customers and employees in those businesses were by and large – or not at all – wearing masks or other face coverings.'

It was not clear to the judge, and at least some of the defendants, what the DPHHS was demanding until Domitrovich made closing arguments Thursday.

'The department understands that there's a lot of concern around these actions, both for the defendants and the community,' he said. 'And we're not asking that businesses be shut down … We're really asking that they operate in a manner consistent with public health orders.'

Wilson, the judge, asked Domitrovich if he had misspoken, noting the department's initial demands for temporary restraining orders against the five businesses.

'In fact, it sought to close every one of them, correct?' Wilson asked.

Domitrovich clarified that the DPHSS actually wanted a restraining order that would reiterate the requirements of the governor's directive, meaning additional violations could put the businesses in contempt of court.

Bullock echoed that sentiment in a news conference Thursday, saying, 'The intent isn’t to punish businesses; it’s actually to get businesses to comply.'

In court, James Murphy, director of communicable disease control and prevention at DPHHS, testified that laboratory staff have been working 12-hour days, seven days a week due to uncontrolled spread of the virus. The overburdened department decided it was time to step in and enforce the governor's mandate where local efforts have failed, he said.

'A lot of this comes from our discussion when we're trying to problem-solve with local health departments, trying to talk about particular venues that have been challenging for one reason or another,' Murphy said. 'So I think a lot of these places came up in our discussions with Flathead County, with our review of where some of the complaints were coming from, and that kind of led to a list of places that needed to be checked out.'

The state inspectors visited other businesses and found some were in compliance while some had relatively minor problems, Murphy said. The five facing lawsuits, he said, 'stood out as the ones that were having the lowest level of compliance.'

Murphy acknowledged that DPHHS officials did not warn any of the businesses they could face lawsuits for noncompliance. The Flathead City-County Health Department had conducted previous inspections and issued warnings, he said.

Tamalee Robinson, the county's interim health officer, said the health department had received about 670 complaints of noncompliance with COVID-19 restrictions. Twenty-four of those complaints were directed at Sykes Diner, more than any other business in the county, while 11 were directed at the Ferndale Market, she said.

Remington Bar And Casino Whitefish Mt

A manager at Sykes Diner testified that three employees – a cashier, a dishwasher and a prep cook – had tested positive for the virus, and the latter two were still isolated at home as of Thursday.

Robinson said the health department reported Sykes and the Ferndale Market to the county attorney's office after giving each business their second notice of violation. The attorney's office took no enforcement action.

Flathead County Attorney Travis Ahner has been open about his reluctance to enforce the governor's mandate. On Oct. 22, the day the lawsuits were announced, Ahner told the Daily Inter Lake that he and local law enforcement officials decided early in the pandemic they wouldn't use criminal charges to enforce public health measures, though civil court orders would be considered.

“These things are more enforceable by the state, DPHHS and the attorney general,' Ahner said at the time.

Fredrickson, the attorney for four of the businesses, called the lawsuits 'frivolous' and said the state failed to define what a 'reasonable' effort to enforce the governor's mandate looks like. He also said the state inspectors failed to ask if any of the maskless customers had valid exemptions.

'This case … in my opinion, was brought for some ulterior reasons. What those all were, I don't know,' Fredrickson said. 'To scare the hell out of other businesses in this community? Maybe. To force these businesses to capitulate before this hearing to things that go beyond this directive? Maybe.'